Appeal court orders new trial in Alberni nurse’s killing

A three-member BC Court of Appeal pannel has ordered a new trial for a Port Alberni man convicted or murdering a male nurse in 2008.

The BC Court of Appeal has ordered a new trial for a Port Alberni man convicted or murdering a male nurse in 2008, the BC Court of Appeal website noted.

The three-member court of appeal judges panel concluded that trial judge, B.C. Supreme Court Justice Ronald McKinnon, erred in his instructions to the jury during the second-degree murder trial of Kim Winslow Rothgordt, 43.

In January 2011, a jury found Rothgordt guilty of second-degree murder in the February 2008 killing of James Shannon, 52.

The Crown’s theory was that after meeting online the two men met at Shannon’s home then had consensual sex. But due to a sexual identity crisis, Rothgordt attacked and killed Shannon.

Rothgordt’s defense was that he was the victim of a violent sexual assault and that he struck Shannon with a hammer in order to defend himself.

The fact that Rothgordt killed Shannon wasn’t disputed during the trial, B.C. Court of Appeal Chief Justice Lance Finch noted. The issue is “…whether the appellant acted in self-defence, was too intoxicated to form the… intent for murder, or was provoked,” Finch said.

In his reasons for allowing the appeal, Finch noted the jury was misdirected on Rothgordt’s defence of provocation, and on the issue of lack of evidence.

McKinnon’s instructions to the jury may have left the jury with a misunderstanding of the provocation defence, which he suggested be considered similar to intoxication. Criminal Code sections were provided, but this wasn’t enough to clear up any confusion.

“I do not consider that the instructions sufficiently explained how the defence of provocation may apply, and had the effect of depriving the appellant of the full force of this defence,” Finch noted.

“Accordingly, I would give effect to this ground of appeal.”

McKinnon’s statements to the jury that a conviction may be based on a lack of evidence, and not providing guidance with it, is an error that “…threatens to contradict the onus that the Crown proves its case beyond a reasonable doubt,” Finch noted.

Justice David Harris and Madam Justice Kathryn Neilson agreed with Finch’s ruling.

reporter@albernivalleynews.com

Twitter.com/AlberniNews

Just Posted

Moms of those killed by illicit opioids take to B.C. Legislature in call for action

Moms Stop the Harm, a nationwide network of families who have lost loved ones to overdoses rally

Alberni wrestler heads to University of the Fraser Valley to compete

Ravi Manhas is one of 10 recruits signed to the Cascades for 2018-19

Taxing Vancouver Island

Big Read: find out which communities are paying the lowest and highest taxes on Vancouver Island

UPDATE: Construction on Hwy. 4 halted after tree crashes into traffic

Trees are being cleared along the highway between Port Alberni and the Tofino-Ucluelet junction.

VIDEO: Canadian toddler caught practising hockey skills in crib

Eli Graveline is getting praise from far and wide as the internet freaks out of cute throwback video

Man shot dead in Surrey ID’d as hockey coach and father of two

Murder of Paul Bennett – a respected Peace Arch Hospital worker and ‘champion of sport’ – ‘not random’

Serial killer Robert Pickton transferred to Quebec: victim’s family

Pickton was convicted in December 2007 of six counts of second degree murder

Canadian Syrian children’s choir not to attend festival over fears about U.S. travel

Many kids are recent immigrants from countries covered by Trump travel ban

Amalgamation fails in North Cowichan and Duncan

North Cowichan says yes, but Duncan says no

B.C. teacher ends Jeopardy! winning streak, taking home US$69,000

Ali Hasan, from New Westminster, has been gaining fans as a “one-man invasion,” says Alex Trebek

Jett Woo highlights 5 Canucks choices on Day 2 of NHL entry draft

WHL star out of Moose Jaw tabbed in Round 2

In a matter of hours, women in Saudi Arabia will be allowed to drive

Change was announced as a royal decree in 2017 by Crown Prince Mohammen bin Salman

Most Read