Water issue raises questions for Alberni reader

Alberni readers poses critical questions about Beaver Creek water issue.

To the Editor,

What’s with Beaver Creek Improvement District leading taxpayers down the garden path to privatizing our drinking water?

On June 2, I sent a request to BCID, under the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, to access information about the proposed P3 agreement.

Earlier in the year, at BCID’s annual general meeting, the private water utility told meeting participants that their proposal to meet the government’s 4-3-2-1 surface water treatment policy included an 8.9 per cent return on investment. I wanted to know what that equated to in terms of dollars over the period of the 21-year agreement. I also wanted other information about the proposal.

About six weeks later, I received a response. Some of the questions I asked remained unanswered. The opening paragraph of the letter said “the numbers” were “as transparent as [BCID] could make them at [the] time.” I wouldn’t doubt it if it’s as transparent as it gets.

In the response, BCID stated the company’s total return on investment would amount to “$3.3 million.”

I then calculated the long-term cost of keeping drinking water in the public domain. The cost of privatizing our drinking water is huge in comparison to the cost of keeping it in public hands. The private water utility estimated the long-term cost for the project to be about $37 million.

For drinking water to remain in public hands it will cost between $16 to $24.5 million depending on whether BCID becomes part of a region-wide water system or continues on its own with treatment at the Stamp River intake. The difference between the two is staggering.

Does someone, in addition to the private water utility, stand to make a high return with low risks at the long-term expense of Beaver Creek taxpayers?

Susan E. Roth,

Beaver Creek

Just Posted

Alberni-Clayoquot Regional District approves one cannabis store, denies another

Stores would have been located across the street from one another in Cherry Creek

UPDATED: Taylor Flats wildfire in the Alberni Valley under control

Fire is located close to Highway 4 near Sproat Lake

EDITORIAL: Plastics ban needs to start from the top

The more people talk about the plastics ban, the more it may catch on elsewhere…

West Coast Amateur in Port Alberni a success

Top overall winner, with a gross score of 140, was Derek Reid from Arbutus Ridge

ARTS AROUND: Last call for cruise ship vendors

Last cruise ship arrives in the Alberni Inlet on July 6

VIDEO: Sproat Lake Fire Department demonstrates sprinkler safety

Demonstration only took 3-5 minutes to create a deadly scenario where no one could survive

’When thunder roars, go indoors’: How to keep safe before lightning strikes

Each year, an estimated 10 deaths and as many as 164 injuries are lightning-related

B.C. rolls out online registration to speed up evacuee processing

Central Okanagan district tests province’s streamlined emergency management digital self-registration

VIDEO: After 73 years, siblings separated by adoption reunite in B.C

Donna Smith of Abbotsford and Clayton Myers of Williams Lake are glad they met each other

B.C.-born Carey Price brings young fan to tears at NHL Awards banquet

Anderson Whitehead first met his hockey idol after his mother died of cancer

Licence issue delays boozing while cruising on BC Ferries

Planned June launch for alcohol sales delayed

Nanaimo a prime market for new plane, Air Canada says

Vice-president previews Airbus A220, praises Nanaimo’s growth in passenger numbers

B.C. school mourns after 13-year-old killed by fallen tree on field trip

Teenager died after being struck and pinned by tree while on a field trip near Sooke

Most Read