Public upset over sale of plywood lots in Alberni

The lack of public consultation on the proposed sale of plywood lots A and B have waterfront advocates and some on city council up in arms.

The City of Port Alberni is considering the sale of plywood lots A and B to the parent company of Canadian Alberni Engineering.

The lack of public consultation and discussion on the proposed sale of plywood lots A and B have both waterfront advocates and members of city council up in arms.

“I have always believed that the key to success for an initiative is to have good public input, with an opportunity for community participation and the resulting support,” said former Port Alberni mayor John Douglas following the current council’s announcement last week that the sale of lots A and B to the parent company of Canadian Alberni Engineering was pending.

“The city is proceeding with the sale of lots A and B of the former plywood mill site to 1076565D B.C. Ltd. This numbered company is wholly owned by Canadian Maritime Engineering.”

They in turn own Canadian Alberni Engineering, Mayor Mike Ruttan announced at city council on May 24. Lots A, B and C are located on the Alberni Inlet waterfront to the south of Western Forest Products’ Alberni Pacific Division sawmill and to the north of the Tseshaht First Nation owned Polly’s Point. Lots C (now known as Canal Beach) and A are adjacent to the water, although Lot A’s foreshore is crown and not city-owned land.

Lot B, located above Lot A, is currently largely used for storage and overflow parking by WFP and events taking place at Canal Beach.

The two lots have had a contentious history. The city originally purchased Lots A, B and C (now know as Canal Beach) from Macmillan Bloedel in 1993 for $1.

(Interested in the history of plywood lots A and B? Read about the initial lease to the port authority in 2014 herethe public’s reaction herecouncil’s discussion about terminating the lease in summer 2015 herethe city’s decision to terminate the lease here and the end of that lease here.)

The catch? A restrictive covenant (now transferred to WFP) which bans overnight stays and any other use than industrial or commercial.

Covenant on Ex-Plywood Mill Property in Alberni


According to the covenant, “the city shall not use the city lands for any purpose other than for industrial or commercial use…and the city shall not use the city lands for any residential or tourist accommodation purposes.”

The lots are also contaminated—they were never properly remediated before the sale, according to an environmental assessment commissioned by the city and carried out by SLR Consulting Ltd. in 2011.

Port Alberni Plywood Site Environmental Assessement


According to the report, “a risk assessment indicated there were no unacceptable human health and ecological risks present at Lot B if the groundwater will not be used as a potable water source. The assessment indicated that for Lot A there could be potential unacceptable adverse health effects for construction and utility workers when exposed to contaminated groundwater and/or soil vapours.”

According to Ruttan, the remediation costs (estimated between $1.63-5.5 million), the covenant and the possibility of job creation were good reasons to sell the lot to CAE.

Both the covenant and remediation costs will be passed on to the buyer, he said.

“There are some significant remediation issues there and we believe that (CAE) has the potential to create significant additional economic activity and significant additional jobs for residents in this community.”

Russell Industries, the parent company of Canadian Alberni Engineering, did not return calls to the News by press time.

Coun. Chris Alemany  disagreed with the thought that the land merely needed to be sold off, pointing to the city’s 2007 Uptown and Waterfront Redevelopment Study.

“The 2007 report identified a desire in the community to try to remove that covenant so the site could move in a different direction,” Alemany said.

While Douglas said that the city had tried to negotiate the covenant during his term without any results, Alemany said that it’s time to try again—and approach WFP “as stakeholders in the community that mutually benefit from the community evolving and diversifying, particularly on the waterfront.”

Until the covenant is lifted, Alemany said, there’s little point worrying over the contamination.


Just Posted

Baby, it’s nasty outside: wind and rain will continue across Vancouver Island

Police warn drivers and pedestrians to use precaution during expected rain and winds

Donation helps North Island College trades students

NIC receives $38,000 equipment donation from Seymour Pacific Developments Ltd

See the Heart of Winter at Port Alberni gallery

Group exhibit runs at DRAW Gallery until February

Future of McLean Mill in question after log pond incident

$200,000 allocated to dam repairs, water quality testing at national historic site

Enjoy a night of laughter at the Capitol Theatre

Outsiders Comedy Night is a fundraiser for STAGES Youth Theatre

Omar Khadr wants changes to bail conditions

‘My life is held in suspension’, says the former Guantanamo Bay detainee

Sissons scores OT winner as Predators beat Canucks 4-3

VIDEO: Vancouver battles back to earn single point in Nashville

High streamflow advisory in effect across the Island

River Forecast Centre issues advisory as Pacific storms batter the coast

Trapped Vancouver Island crash survivor celebrates second chance at life

“Life is good now. It’s good to be alive.”

Lions announce seven members of coaching staff not coming back for 2019

The operational moves come two days after the Lions announced DeVone Claybrooks as the team’s new head coach

VIDEO: Kitten rescued from under school bus in Duncan

School staff have affectionately called kitten “Axle”

$12K awarded to atheist family who oppose Christmas, Hanukkah in B.C. classroom

Gary Mangel,May Yasue said holidays, Remembrance Day and Valentine’s Day not appropriate in preschool

Coach accused of sexual assault says apology letter was misinterpreted

Dave Brubaker has pleaded not guilty to one count of sexual assault and one count of invitation to sexual touching

Give the gift of nature this holiday season

Please don’t be mad, but I bought you a moose

Most Read