Truck routes proposed by the city in 2015. NEWS FILE PHOTO

Truck route in Port Alberni set to ‘low priority’ for now

Cost, location biggest concerns for city council

Years of debate about industrial trucks in Port Alberni has led to an impasse, as city council voted Feb. 19 to move the issue to a “low priority” on their status report.

In late 2015, city staff came up with a list of options for a designated truck route in Port Alberni, in response to concern from Third Avenue businesses and Anderson Avenue residents who do not want heavy industry traffic on their roads. Options included a $10 million waterfront industrial route and a $20 million Ring Road outside of city limits.

READ: TRUCK TALK: The truck stops here

According to director of development services Scott Smith, the price was a challenge for council.

“There was a lot of work that was done, but the cost is significant,” he said during a budget meeting on Thursday, Feb. 1. “We’re taking a step back. What sort of volume of traffic are we talking about? Is there a way we can consider a truck route that isn’t $10 million?”

City staff completed a truck count in 2017, looking at all vehicles in multiple locations over three days. This resulted in 1,500 pages worth of data.

READ: Alberni city staff to take on truck count

Smith proposed a study that would take this data, crunch the numbers, do some analysis and come up with improvements for the city’s road infrastructure for a potential truck route—one that is not in the multi-million-dollar range.

Smith confirmed that a consultation would look at options “within the existing road infrastructure,” which would be primarily the Harbour Road waterfront route. The city acquired a portion of Harbour Road, as well as a statutory right of way from Redford Street, when they purchased the Catalyst lagoon.

This consultation would cost approximately $40,000, but council voted down the motion in the 2018-2022 draft financial plan.

“We’ve done a truck count I don’t know how many times,” said Councillor Jack McLeman. “[With] this money, there’s going to be another consultant that’s going to look at the stuff we’ve already got. I think we’re going around this thing in circles forever.”

Councillor Sharie Minions took issue with Port Alberni’s “vibrant waterfront” being interrupted by a truck route.

“I’m strongly opposed to spending any money that’s going to move us towards putting more heavy industry trucks on our waterfront,” she said. “I don’t think that alleviates the problem of having them on Third and Anderson.”

With no money invested in the next step of the project, it came to a halt during last Monday’s meeting of council.

“It’s been dealt with to the extent that we can,” said Smith.

Minions suggested removing the item from council’s status report, or setting it to a low priority. “We did not support funding to take it forward,” she said. “Having it on there as a high priority if we didn’t put funds forward just seems kind of pointless.”

Councillor Ron Paulson did not want to take the item off entirely.

“As a council, we’ve indicated to the businesses on Third Avenue and the people on Anderson that we would look into this,” said Paulson. “To be quite honest, I think that we need to find a solution.”

Because the item is tied up in budget discussions, council agreed to set it to a low priority for now.

But discussion of truck traffic in the Alberni Valley has not come to a halt. In a later interview, Councillor Chris Alemany made some suggestions for reducing the impact of truck traffic on city streets.

“If we can limit and direct where heavy truck traffic goes, we can limit the wear and tear on the roads,” he said.

The city did this once before, by putting a weight restriction on the Gertrude Street bridge so that trucks are kept to Beaver Creek Road.

Alemany pointed out that Port Alberni also has a major highway running through the community that is funded by the provincial government, rather than city taxpayers.

“Unfortunately, that doesn’t help the Anderson and Third Avenue situation,” he added.

There are traffic calming measures that can be applied to residential roads, to keep trucks from travelling as fast as they have been. The city can enforce lower speed limits or add speed humps, as has been suggested by Anderson residents. But, said, Alemany, these are somewhat drastic steps. Engineering measures, such as lane narrowings and curb extensions, can also calm traffic.

“It encourages people to actually stop, and makes it safer for pedestrians to cross,” said Alemany. “It’s worth having that public discussion.”

There are longer-term solutions for trucks in the Alberni Valley that also keep them away from the waterfront, such as a bypass outside of the city, or a revival of the rail system, but these measures are within tens of millions of dollars.

“Those are larger solutions that would require some provincial help,” said Alemany.

Just Posted

Vancouver Island wife brings husband back to life with CPR, thanks to 911 dispatcher

‘The only reason he was alive was that 10 minutes of CPR before paramedics got there’

Capitol Theatre in Port Alberni hopes to ‘raise the reds’

Lily Diotte of Swale Rock Cafe is fundraising to replace the theatre’s red curtains

Alberni’s development soccer program doubles in size

Development practice had hardly started, but there were already more than 30… Continue reading

Catalyst Paper to sell U.S. mills to Chinese company

Sale will allow company to focus on B.C. interests, says president Ned Dwyer

Alberni university zeroes in on disability and poverty

BY MIKE YOUDS SPECIAL TO THE NEWS The road to poverty can… Continue reading

Trans Mountain pipeline: How we got here

A look at the Kinder Morgan expansion, decades in the making

VIDEO: B.C. woman praises burn fund after boat explosion in 1978

White Rock woman was 16 years old when she was left with second- and third-degree burns

B.C.’s Ryan Craig, Vegas Golden Knights chase history

Local product behind bench for expansion team’s incredible championship run

CP rail workers give strike notice

Employees could walk out as early as Tuesday at 7 p.m. PT

RCMP investigating after gunshots fired in Courtenay

Comox Valley RCMP officers are investigating after gunshots rang out in Courtenay… Continue reading

Suspected scammer attempts to use Black Press newspaper to dupe woman

Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre offers tips after Langley resident received suspicious call

Vote points to abortion being legalized in Ireland

Voters asked whether to keep or repeal Eighth Amendment to Roman Catholic Ireland’s Constitution

COLUMN: Women’s breasts really aren’t that big a deal

A follow on some Princeton, B.C., students gained considerable exposure when they dropped their bras

Most Read